book review: Eonomics should outweigh Black nationalism

Against Black Nationalism: Garvey, Randolph & the Class Alternative
By Paul Prescod
OR Books, 2026
Racism certainly bedevils U.S. society, but is racism the largest obstacle to African Americans, or is it few pathways to decent jobs?
Paul Prescod argues in Against Black Nationalism that what African American working-class people need is access to decent jobs, grounded in organized labor.
Prescod contrasts two 1920s to 1940s movements, Marcus Garvey’s early 1920s Back to Africa movement, with A. Philip Randolph’s Brotherhood of Sleeping Car Porters (BSCP), a springboard for economic activism.
Jamaican Marcus Garvey (1887-1940) marshaled the African American community into his Universal Negro Improvement Association (UNIA) immediately after World War I. The 1919 “Red Summer,” with lynchings and urban racial attacks, left African Americans feeling betrayed, particularly those who fought in the war. Thousands bought stock in Garvey’s enterprise as he mobilized working people with promises of Black-owned business development, including the “Black Star” steamship line. Garvey proclaimed himself “President of Africa” and said his movement would uplift colonized Africa to European standards. His message of Black pride and separatism inspired people who invested in his various business schemes. Garvey was imprisoned for tax fraud in 1923 and deported to Jamaica in 1927.
Prescod contrasts Garvey’s nationalism with the economic uplift through unionization efforts of A. Philip Randolph (1889-1979). A socialist, Randolph helped organize the BSCP, fighting from 1925 until 1937, when the union negotiated a contract with the Pullman Company, operator of railroad sleeping cars and one of the nation’s largest employers of African Americans. At the same time, the Congress of Industrial Organizations (CIO) was launching new unions like the United Auto Workers (UAW) and the United Steelworkers (USW), bringing millions into the union movement without discrimination based on gender or race.
In 1941, as U.S. entry into World War II loomed, Randolph launched his March on Washington Movement (MOWM), demanding desegregation of the U.S. defense industry and the armed services. Overnight, the MOWM attracted local organizing, as thousands prepared to march on the U.S. Capitol. A panicked President Franklin D. Roosevelt issued Executive Order 8802, mandating non-discrimination in defense industries, opening industrial jobs to thousands. Randolph called off the March in response. The MOWM continued its pressure campaign, and in 1948, President Harry Truman issued Executive Order 9981, desegregating the U.S. military.
Prescod contrasts these two very different movements with the current Black Lives Matter movement and others. In his analysis, gaining access to management positions and exposing racist practices is not sufficient; the prevalent need is economic uplift and opportunity, particularly through unionization. Prescod writes: “The current framework of anti-racism focuses more on individual atonement and interpersonal relations instead of broader political economy.” He argues that economic uplift and universal programs that affect everyone should be the priority. “A political program should speak to the concrete daily grievances experienced by working people, of whom black people are overrepresented. Day in and day out, working people of all races struggle with health care, student debt, low wages, bad housing, an underfunded public education system, and environmental degradation.”
Prescod masterfully uses these two 20th-century movements to address current issues. In his viewpoint, blaming racism is insufficient without creating economic stabilization and access to decent jobs.